Eddie Cash & Associates, Allen Tate Realtors
Search
Brick home entrance with white porch columns, an oak door, gray stone steps and copper-orange autumn foliage.

Chatham Mills Changed Hands in September. The Plan Is to Fill Its Quiet Hours.

"Make us a nice third place where we can hang out." Chris Ehrenfeld said that over lunch on September 17, according to the Chatham Journal's "3 Guys from Pittsboro" interview. He had met with the Chatham Marketplace board the night before and asked it to consider outdoor live music on Friday or Saturday evenings.

Two weeks earlier, he had bought Chatham Mills.

Ehrenfeld has said the businesses already there are staying. The mill does have empty space, and he wants to fill it with businesses that bring people in at times of day when the building now sits quiet. A gym that opens early, music on weekend evenings, a building drivers can actually see from the road. Each of those changes when Chatham Mills is in use, and none of them asks anyone currently there to leave.

What sold on September 3

Ehrenfeld owns and runs BOLD Companies. On September 3, he bought the 28-acre mill property off Hillsboro Street from longtime owner Tom Roberts, along with a 3.64-acre parcel just to the north. Chapelboro reported the total at nearly $12 million, and the site has operated as a retail center since 1997. The Chatham Journal put the combined price at about $11.8 million.

The tenant list is familiar to anyone who shops there. The main building is anchored by Chatham Marketplace, the grocery co-op. It also houses The Sycamore restaurant, the drug development research company Xyzagen, and five other businesses. The Chatham Mills Farmers Market runs there weekly from April through October, and the event space Forest Hall is on the property too.

BOLD's announcement said its commercial real estate arm will handle leasing, and that the work includes keeping and supporting the current tenants. Ehrenfeld spelled out the order of priorities in the statement Chapelboro published:

"Our first goal is to preserve and improve what is already here. We have a nice mix of tenants currently and about 25,000 square feet to fill. We intend to get that space occupied, which will bring more life and energy to the property."

He said much the same in a September 9 conversation reported by the Chatham Journal. There he called the mill the "centerpiece" of any future development and said, "I'm going to preserve what's here."

Roughly half the building is in use

The empty space is easier to grasp in numbers. At the September 17 lunch, Ehrenfeld gave the Chatham Journal a rough breakdown of the building:

  • About 77,000 square feet in total
  • About 40,000 square feet occupied
  • About 27,000 square feet vacant
  • About 10,000 square feet used for storage

So businesses use a little over half of the building. That vacant figure is a bit higher than the "about 25,000 square feet" in BOLD's announcement. Both are his own estimates, given about two weeks apart.

The vacant space and the storage level break down into three very different pieces:

  1. A front space of about 7,000 square feet. It has had tenants before, and Ehrenfeld said BOLD was in "final talks" with a gym for it. The gym has not been named. The latest reporting describes a deal that was close but not signed.
  2. Two rooms of about 10,000 square feet each. Ehrenfeld said neither has ever been occupied in its current commercial layout, and no prospective tenant has been named for either one.
  3. A storage level between the upper and lower floors. It is not part of the vacant count. Once it is cleared and cleaned, he thinks about 10,000 square feet there could serve businesses that need overflow space.

Two big empty rooms in a historic mill could become almost anything. Ehrenfeld has said what he wants them to do. "We definitely want to activate the place," he told the Chatham Journal, describing businesses that draw more people and "help make the mill useful at different hours."

The mill already runs on a short clock

"Different hours" makes more sense next to the calendar Chatham Mills keeps now. Here is the scheduled programming on the property this fall, as its businesses publish it:

  • Saturday, 8 a.m. to noon. The Chatham Mills Farmers Market, April through October. The Haw River Crawdaddies played the October 10 market.
  • Friday, 11 a.m. to noon. Line dancing classes at Forest Hall, presented with Chatham Social Club. Classes cost $25 and are open to all skill levels.
  • Tuesday through Saturday, 5 to 9 p.m. Dinner at The Sycamore, with live piano and a Wednesday Jazz Night.

Most scheduled programming falls on Saturday mornings, one late morning on Fridays, and dinner on weeknights. A gym would bring people in early on weekdays, and outdoor music on Friday or Saturday nights would add something outdoors on weekend evenings alongside dinner service. The Journal's reporters described how the two could connect. Someone in an early gym class could find the co-op before the lunch rush and come back for dinner another day.

Neither of those is settled. The gym lease was unsigned as of the latest report. The music idea is now with the Chatham Marketplace board, and the co-op decides whether, when and how it fits the store's operation. We found no newer announcement on either between September 26 and October 12.

What has already changed

The first visible work is easy to miss. Tenants had told Ehrenfeld the trees made the building hard to see from the road. "We're not actually taking down the trees. We're going to limb them up," he said. The trimming was finished within a few days of the September 17 lunch, and an insurer had also flagged some limbs that needed cutting back.

Power washing, landscaping and other upkeep are on the early list, without a full timetable. The existing signs stay for now, and Ehrenfeld said he expects to consider more signage within Pittsboro's rules.

The longer timeline stretches over years. In the September 9 conversation, Ehrenfeld described where he wants to be in five years. He wants the mill buildings fully leased, a long-range plan for the rest of the site, which the Journal puts at more than 30 acres near downtown, and construction started on a first phase. He has not shown a finished site plan, a list of uses, or a construction schedule. On the leasing, he told the Journal, "certainly I expect to have that long before five years from now."

The same push for more hours, elsewhere on Hillsboro Street and around the Circle

Chatham Mills is not the only spot in town stretching its hours. Pittsboro's newest food businesses this fall are built around more than one time of day.

Nonna's Café soft-opened September 18 in the SoCo development off the Circle, in the space Havoc Brewing used to occupy. It held its grand opening on September 19. The Triangle Food Blog describes it as an Italian coffee shop in the morning that becomes an Italian wine bar later in the day. Chapelboro lists its hours as 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. Owners Dana and Jim Rumbold are building out a full kitchen for the Italian restaurant La Cucina della Nonna, which Chapelboro reports is targeting spring 2027.

Sippers Cafe & Bakery held its grand opening August 8 at 697 Hillsboro St., Unit 101. It runs as a coffee and bakery social enterprise that supports youth training.

In Chatham Park, one longtime kitchen changed its purpose. Chef Sera Cuni and Susan White opened Café Root Cellar on Suttles Road in 2017. They ended regular restaurant service in mid-September to put more time into Feed-Well Fridges, their nonprofit that rescues food and stocks free fridges across Chatham County. Chapelboro reported that the Pittsboro kitchen will cook for Feed-Well for now. The plan is to move that work into a new commissary kitchen later.

Two openings announced for MOSAIC at Chatham Park are still on the way. a Tavolo Italian Eatery at 367 Freedom Parkway plans wood-fired pizza, house-made pasta and a full bar. Its website still says it opens in October 2026, with no specific date. Pecan Jacks Ice Cream · Candy Kitchen at 60 Mosaic Blvd. still lists its Pittsboro location as coming soon.

The rest of the October calendar, and the market's winter dates

Saturdays at the Chatham Mills Farmers Market keep their 8 a.m. to noon hours through the end of October. From November through January, the market moves to 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. Dates through the end of the year:

  • October 16: Y2K Kids in MOSAIC's Blast from the Past music series.
  • October 16, 23 and 30, then November 6, 13, 20 and 27: Friday line dancing at Forest Hall, 11 a.m. to noon.
  • October 17 and 18: Pittsboro Pride at The Plant.
  • October 23: Bazaar Night Market at The Plant. Also that night, Witches Brew & Bonfire runs 6 to 8 p.m. at Starrlight Mead, 130 Lorax Lane.
  • October 25: Apple Fest at The Plant.
  • October 29: Halloween at the Market at the separate Pittsboro Farmers Market, held at the Downtown Pittsboro Pop-Up Park, 50 W. Salisbury St. Expect trick-or-treating, 4-H activities and a children's costume parade.
  • November 25: Pre-Thanksgiving Market at Chatham Mills, noon to 3 p.m., with fresh turkeys, sweet potatoes and last-minute holiday groceries.
  • December 5, 12 and 19: Holidays at the Market at Chatham Mills, 10 a.m. to 1 p.m., with local makers and artisans alongside the produce vendors.

If you own a home near Hillsboro Street, the mill's next tenants could shape what your block feels like, and that can matter when you sell. Eddie Cash & Associates follows these changes around Pittsboro closely, and we're happy to talk through what they could mean for your home. Get Your Free Home Valuation and we'll walk you through what homes near Chatham Mills are selling for right now.

Work With Us

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!
Follow Us